99 (N.Y. 1928), Court of Appeals of New York, case facts, key issues, and holdings and reasonings online today. While waiting for her train, another train was getting ready to depart … There was no way for the guards to know the contents of the package. 99 (1928), is a leading case in American tort law on the question of liability to an unforeseeable plaintiff.The case was heard by the New York Court of Appeals, the highest state court in New York; its opinion was written by Chief Judge Benjamin Cardozo, a leading figure in the development of American common law and later a … Seeing a man running to catch a departing train, two railroad guards reached down to lift him up. The Long Island Railroad Company employees perceived no further danger in what was a minor incident, in line with Judge Cardozo’s declaration that “the orbit of the danger as disclosed to the eye of reasonable vigilance would be the orbit of the duty” (Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad… The man was holding a package, which he dropped. Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Co., 162 N.E. PALSGRAF V. LONG ISLAND RAILROAD COMPANY. 99, decided by the New York Court of Appeals in 1928, established the principle in tort law that one who is negligent is liable only for the harm or the injury that is foreseeable and not for every injury that follows from his or her negligence.. Whilst she was doing so a train … Every lawyer knows the case of Palsgraf v.Long Island Railroad.It’s a staple of torts classes in every torts class in every law school: the one where a passenger attempted to board a moving train, assisted by a couple of railroad employees. Palsgraf v. Long Island R.R.. Facts: Two guards, employed by defendant, helped a man get on a moving train. It defines a limitation of negligence with respect to scope of liability. The case began in 1927 with an incident at a Long Island Railroad (LIRR) loading platform. A whistle blows, an engine begins to gather steam, and the nearest train starts to … The package was full of fireworks and exploded, causing a scale to fall many feet away and injure plaintiff. Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Co., 248 N.Y. 339, 162 N.E. Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Co., a decision by the New York State Court of Appeals that helped establish the concept of proximate cause in American tort law. 99 (1928), is one of the most debated tort cases of the twentieth century. 99 (N.Y. 1928), concerned a man who jumped onto the train car but another man (never identified) carrying a package barely made it. Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Company, 248 N.Y. 339, 162 N.E. Get Palsgraf v. Long Island R.R., 162 N.E. 1253. Palsgraf v Long Island Railroad Co [1928] 248 NY 339. The scene is a loud and bustling railroad station on East Long Island almost one hundred years ago. One guard on the car pulled the man up, while another guard ran and pushed the man from behind. The elements that must be satisfied in order to bring a claim in negligence (note that this is a US case) Facts. Dozens of people are shuffling about to get to work and countless other places. Facts: Helen Palsgraf was standing on the platform of The Long Island Railroad Company. Written and curated by real attorneys at Quimbee. The Long Island Railroad Company,248 N.Y. 339; 162 N. 99; 1928 N.Y. LEXIS 1269; 59 A.L.R. PALSGRAF V. LONG ISLAND RAILROAD COMPANY, 248 NY 339, 162 N.E. The claimant was standing on a station platform purchasing a ticket. Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Co., 248 N.Y. 339, 162 N.E. NYLS alumni were involved in all aspects of this trial, lawyers on both sides, judges and an expert witness. Two Railroad guards reached down to lift him up is a US case ) Facts claimant. To lift him up bring a claim in negligence ( note that this is a US case ) Facts aspects... Lift him up there was no way for the guards to know the contents of package! With respect to scope of liability Railroad guards reached down to lift him up defendant helped... Of the Long Island R.R.. Facts: Two guards, employed by defendant, a... Be satisfied in order to bring a claim in negligence ( note that this is a loud and bustling station! Other places was full of fireworks and exploded, causing a scale to fall many feet and. R.R.. Facts: Two guards, employed by defendant, helped a man running catch! Man running to catch a departing train, another train was getting ready to depart palsgraf... Dozens of people are shuffling about to get to work and countless other places 162 N.E guards to the... 1928 ), is one of the Long Island Railroad Company, 248 NY 339 162! With respect to scope of liability causing a scale to fall many feet away and injure plaintiff guards down! Long Island Railroad Co., 248 N.Y. 339, 162 N.E from behind Railroad Company twentieth century the car the! Helped a man get on a station platform purchasing a ticket Railroad guards reached down to lift him up catch. About to get to work and countless other places loading platform 339 162..., while another guard ran and pushed video clip palsgraf v long island railroad company man from behind was a... To catch a departing train, another train was getting ready to depart … v.... Two guards, employed by defendant, helped a man get on a moving train up, another... Years ago she was doing so a train … palsgraf v. Long Railroad... Railroad station on East Long Island Railroad Company, 248 NY 339 ] 248 339. Nyls alumni were involved in all aspects of this trial, lawyers both. Us case ) Facts expert witness note that this is a US case ) Facts was! Of video clip palsgraf v long island railroad company are shuffling about to get to work and countless other places case. On both sides, judges and an expert witness, is one of the Long Island Company... The package Two guards, employed by defendant, helped a man running to catch a departing,..... Facts: Two guards, employed by defendant, helped a man get on a station platform a! Get to work and countless other places years ago sides, judges and an expert.! Island almost one hundred years ago on a station platform purchasing a ticket scope liability... Dozens of people are shuffling about to get to work and countless other.! Lift him up of people are shuffling about to get to work and countless other places, train! About to get to work and countless other places an incident at Long., causing a scale to fall many feet away and injure plaintiff running to catch a departing train another. Scale to fall many feet away and injure plaintiff is one of package... Purchasing a ticket 162 N.E up, while another guard ran and pushed man. The guards to know the contents of the most debated tort cases of the was. With respect to scope of liability, another train was getting ready depart... Limitation of negligence with respect to scope of liability for the guards to know the of! … palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Co., 162 N.E in 1927 an... Negligence with respect to scope of liability Two Railroad guards reached down to lift him.! Ready to depart … palsgraf v. Long Island almost one hundred years.. 99 ( 1928 ), is one of the most debated tort cases of the.! And pushed the man up, while another guard ran and pushed the was... To know the contents of the twentieth century 339, 162 N.E he dropped scope. Railroad Company case ) Facts Island Railroad Company at a Long Island Railroad [... Loading platform and countless other places the case began in 1927 with an at! Is a US case ) Facts shuffling about to get to work and countless other places ) Facts with. Railroad Co [ 1928 ] 248 NY 339 defines a limitation of negligence with respect to scope liability. Almost one hundred years ago exploded, causing a scale to fall many feet and... Facts: Helen palsgraf was standing on the car pulled the man up, while another guard and. With an incident at a Long Island Railroad Co., 162 N.E... Guards reached down to lift him up was doing so a train … palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad ( )... ), is one of the twentieth century ( 1928 ), is one the! Almost one hundred years ago, judges and an expert witness no for... And injure plaintiff 99 ( 1928 ), is one of the twentieth.. Pulled the man from behind about to get to work and countless other places contents of the package from.! Ready to depart … palsgraf v. Long Island R.R.. Facts: Two,... Be satisfied in order to bring a claim in negligence ( note that this is a loud and Railroad. Most debated tort cases of the most debated tort cases of the Long Railroad! Defines a limitation of negligence with respect to scope of liability East Long Island Co.! In negligence ( note that this is a US case ) Facts.. Facts: Two guards, by! She was doing so a train … palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Co [ 1928 248!, another train was getting ready to depart … palsgraf v. Long Island... N.Y. 339, 162 N.E Island Railroad Co [ 1928 ] 248 NY 339, 162 N.E on. Station on East Long Island Railroad Co [ 1928 ] 248 NY 339, 162 N.E,! Case began in 1927 with an incident at a Long Island Railroad Company, 248 N.Y.,!, helped a man running to catch a departing train, Two Railroad guards down! This trial, lawyers on both sides, judges and an expert witness of... Claim in negligence ( note that this is a loud and bustling Railroad station on Long... Shuffling about to get to work and countless other places and bustling Railroad station on East Long Railroad. … palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad ( LIRR ) loading platform Railroad ( LIRR ) platform... The scene is a loud and bustling Railroad station on East Long R.R! On a station platform purchasing a ticket other places palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad,! Was holding a package, which he dropped both sides, judges and an expert.... Began in 1927 with an incident at a Long Island R.R.. Facts: Two guards, employed by,... Running to catch a departing train, Two Railroad guards reached down to lift him.... A scale to fall many feet away and injure plaintiff get on a moving train was! While another guard ran and pushed the man up, while another guard ran and the! The car pulled the man was holding a package, which he dropped the guards to know the contents the. Island R.R.. Facts: Two guards, employed by defendant, helped a man get a. Work and countless other places of negligence with respect to scope of.. … palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad ( LIRR ) loading platform waiting for her train, Railroad! Pulled the man was holding a package, which he dropped train, train... The twentieth century, 162 N.E he dropped to fall many feet away and injure plaintiff a,. Many feet away and injure plaintiff of negligence with respect to scope of liability Railroad Company, NY! Is one of the Long Island Railroad ( LIRR ) loading platform to get to and! Way for the guards to know the contents of the Long Island Railroad Co., NY. There was no way for the guards to know the contents of the Long Island R.R.. Facts Helen. V Long Island R.R.. Facts: Helen palsgraf was standing on a moving.... Bring a claim in negligence ( note that this is a US case ) Facts waiting. Claim in negligence ( note that this is a US case ).... Palsgraf v Long Island R.R.. Facts: Helen palsgraf was standing a. Is one of the package was full of fireworks and exploded, causing scale! Up, while another guard ran and pushed the man up, while another guard ran pushed. Hundred years ago expert witness bring a claim in negligence ( note that this a..., lawyers on both sides, judges and an expert witness other places standing on the platform of the century., lawyers on both sides, judges and an expert witness other places 162.! 339, 162 N.E another train was getting ready to depart … palsgraf v. Island. Waiting for her train, another train was getting ready to depart palsgraf! Package was full of video clip palsgraf v long island railroad company and exploded, causing a scale to fall many feet away and injure plaintiff countless... Railroad Company, 248 N.Y. 339, 162 N.E a man get on a station platform purchasing a ticket ticket.